The news that AOL released the search histories of 658,000 of its users is renewing calls for federal legislation to protect consumer privacy online.
In the wake of the disclosure, Representative Edward Markey (D-Mass.) urged his colleagues to take action on privacy legislation he proposed in February of this year.
"Technology is the engine which will drive our economy into the next century, but the success of this technology balances on the public trust," Markey said. "If 2005 was the year of the data breach, I want to make sure that 2006 is the year of safeguarding the privacy of American citizens by introducing legislation to prevent the stockpiling of private citizens personal data."
Mandatory Deletion
Markey's bill is H.R. 4731, the Eliminate Warehousing of Consumer Internet Data Act (EWOCID). The bill would require Internet companies to destroy obsolete electronic data, and particularly data that could be used to individually identify consumers. The bill would also instruct the Federal Trade Commission to set up standards for the maintenance and destruction of data, and enforce the provisions of the law.
The language of the bill does not define when data should be declared "obsolete," and does allow companies to retain data for "legitimate business purposes" or to satisfy court orders.
"In this digital information age, the personal data we hand over to dozens of Web sites are the keys which unlock the personal lives and valuable possessions of millions of Americans," Representative Markey said. "This stored-up data about consumers' Internet use should not be needlessly kept in perpetuity, inviting data thieves or fraudsters, or disclosure through judicial fishing expeditions."
Markey's bill has languished in committee since it was introduced, and there is no indication from the Republican leadership in the House as to when any action will be taken on the bill.
"It's worth having a debate about what type of protections [those corporations] should have," said Dave McGuire, director of communications for the Center for Democracy and Technology. "It is also reasonable to ask companies about what they're doing and what their plans are for data. Companies should disclose if there are procedures in place to prevent misuse." McGuire also added that there is no government standard regarding data collection and storage .
Previous Federal Privacy Laws
Congress has typically taken a hands-off approach to privacy, but it has responded in the past to high-profile privacy invasions. During the Senate hearings on Judge Robert Bork's nomination to the Supreme Court, for instance, reporters obtained lists of the movies he had rented (none were particularly salacious). Congress responded by passing the Video Privacy Protection Act, which bars the release of such information.
Some years earlier, a stalker obtained the address of actress Rebecca Schaeffer from the California Department of Motor Vehicles and shot her when she answered his knock at the door. That tragic event spurred passage of the federal Drivers Privacy Protection Act.
|